It should be customary to obtain the express consent of the undertakings concerned in the Member State of export before the visit is definitively scheduled. As soon as an investigation has been initiated, the authorities shall communicate the full text of the written complaint received pursuant to Article 11(1) to known exporters (40) and to the authorities of the member State of export and make it available to other interested parties concerned upon request. Due account shall be taken of the protection of confidential information referred to in paragraph 4. (4) This standard is met where the facts show that the granting of a subsidy, without having been legally conditional on export performance, is actually linked to actual or projected export earnings. The mere granting of a subsidy to the companies which have compensated shall not be considered an export subsidy within the meaning of this provision for that reason alone. 16 The Uruguay Round negotiations in the field of agriculture were not easy and went beyond the traditional problems of access to imports [6]. Negotiators discussed disciplines on all measures concerning agricultural trade, including domestic agricultural policy and agricultural export subsidies. The Agreement on Agriculture contains specific commitments to reduce support and protection in the areas of domestic support, export subsidies and market access. In the event of a conflict between the WTO Agreements and the Agreement on Agriculture, the provisions of the WTO Agreement shall prevail. 34 The top three developed countries, and in particular the United States, have traditionally played the role of “guardian” of fair competition in the multilateral trading system. A significant number of CVM cases in the United States have only been initiated and not closed, reflecting the introduction of trade-restrictive bilateral agreements. A financial contribution from a government is not a grant unless it provides a benefit.
In many cases, such as a cash grant, the existence of a benefit and its assessment will be clear. In some cases, however, the issue of benefits will be more complex. For example, when does a loan, a capital injection or the purchase of property by a government bring an advantage? Although the SCM Agreement does not provide complete guidance on these issues, the Appellate Body (Canada Aircraft) has decided that the existence of a market advantage must be determined (i.e. on the basis of what the consignee could have obtained in the market). In the context of countervailing duties, Art. 14 of the SCM Convention, some guidance for determining whether certain types of measures give rise to a benefit. In the context of multilateral disciplines, however, the question of the meaning of benefits is not fully understood. (47) For the purposes of this paragraph, producers are considered to be related to exporters or importers only if: (a) one of them directly or indirectly controls the other; or (b) both are controlled directly or indirectly by a third party; or (c) directly or indirectly control a third party together where there are grounds to believe or suspect that the effects of the relationship are likely to induce the manufacturer concerned to behave differently from that of independent producers. For the purposes of this paragraph, control of others shall be deemed to be exercised if the former is legally or operationally able to exercise restraint or guidance in respect of the latter.
These timetables include commitments made by each WTO Member Party to allow certain foreign goods or service suppliers access to their markets. Timetables are an integral part of the agreements. In the printed version, these tables include about 30,000 pages for all WTO Members. The authority within the Ministry of Commerce dealing with countervailing duty applications is the Import Administration. If that body determines that a countervailable subsidy is being granted, and the United States. . . .
Comments are closed.